Postgraduate: Lisa Lee – Environmental and Economic Impact of Water Scarcity and Market Reform on the Mooki Basin (was US72)

Abstract

Geographical factors are defining the extreme variability in climate and water supply in Australia and, in the past, this was used as a rationale for the construction of large irrigation projects to deliver water to rural, urban, and industrial users. During this ‘expansionary’ phase of Australia’s water use sector, the cost of augmenting supply was relatively low and environmental considerations were secondary to the development imperative. As a result, water resources became over-allocated for extractive uses spurred on by consistent underpricing of water, which indicated a failure to reflect the true cost of water supply. As Australia’s water economy entered a ‘mature’ phase, it was no longer possible to increase supply cheaply as the most easily accessible water resources had already been captured. This was followed by widespread environmental degradation manifested in the Murray- Darling Basin, the nation’s largest river basin which hosts much of Australia’s agricultural production. Consequently, the focus shifted towards demand management, leading to a myriad of regulation aimed at increasing the allocative efficiency of scarce water resources. Towards this end, substantial government funding was injected into the various initiatives throughout the water reform process. Despite the on-going government activities in the area of water reform, the understanding of the actual economic impact and environmental outcomes of various water policies in practice remains limited. In the absence of such understanding, the effectiveness of various government water initiatives is ambiguous and inevitably compromised. The present study addresses this knowledge gap by establishing a method for evaluating the economic and environmental outcomes of environmentally-oriented polices that affect irrigated industries in a catchment. The method is based on an integrated biophysical and economic modelling approach, which enables spatial relationships to be captured accurately allowing a more realistic analysis. Information generated from a computer based biophysical simulation model form the basis of an economic optimization model with constraints pertaining to environmental targets and water supply limits. The economic model consists of a linear programming and dynamic programming component, and involves the optimisation of resource use from a catchment manager’s perspective, seeking to achieve efficient resource use but at the same time conform to given environmental objectives. This two-stage modelling process was required to determine the optimal intra-seasonal and inter-seasonal water allocation, given various catchment environmental targets. The interdisciplinary approach enables the economic and ecological outcomes of the catchment management policies to be simulated and assessed at a spatially explicit scale, due to the link to Geographical Information Systems (GIS) in the biophysical model. The overall objective was to create a decision-making framework that could be used to determine the least-cost means of meeting environmental targets and resource constraints. The solutions to the analysis are directly applicable to the case study, the Mooki catchment in northern New South Wales (NSW), but with an adaptable framework that can be applied to other catchments. Specific objectives include an evaluation of the possibility of using alternative irrigation systems, as well as an evaluation of the benefits that can be realised by establishing water market, in the light of environmentally-oriented catchment policies for the case study. The economic cost of achieving environmental targets pertaining to environmental flow requirements and salinity reduction, in the form of end-of-valley salinity targets, was explicitly calculated through the economic model. While salinity targets have been set for NSW catchments, the practicality of such targets is in question, given the substantial reductions in water allocation to irrigation activities, which is one of the key contributors to deep-drainage. An additional objective in this study was therefore to investigate the value of having deep drainage targets. A further consideration is the effect of “external agents” in the form of government plans to buyback entitlements from irrigation districts, or the possibility of significant water rights purchases from mining industries. The implications of external water market entrants on the regional agricultural industry were examined. Some conclusions and recommendations drawn from the results of this thesis are as follows:

• Alternative irrigation systems, including pivot and drip irrigation, are beneficial to irrigators in the Mooki basin, improving their water use efficiency and productivity. Pivot irrigation systems were shown to be the optimal system for most of the catchment, while drip irrigation systems are less economically viable due to the high cost of investment. Significantly, the viability of these irrigation systems is reliant on the security of water supply. It has been demonstrated that where groundwater is used in conjunction with pivot or drip, profit is consistently higher compared to where surface water is used. This relates to the uncertainty of river flow in an ephemeral system, which result in irregular irrigation water availability and, consequently, lower crop yields. To encourage investment in water efficient technologies, it is important there are ample and secure water supplies. Considering the recent cuts in groundwater entitlements in the Mooki basin, and the prospect of future reductions in both surface and ground water rights, irrigators in the region may be reluctant to make the investment. This is especially the case where the capital requirement for water efficient technologies is substantial. It reiterates the importance of secure water rights and clear policy implications for future supplies.

• It was found that the initial area-based water licensing led to an inefficient distribution of water amongst irrigators, and that a fully functional water market would enhance basin profitability since water is shifted to higher value uses in the downstream-most region of the Mooki. This leads to an efficient outcome, as irrigation areas contract and leaves more land available for conservation purposes. The presence of a water market also augments the value of irrigation technologies, leading to a shift away from tradition furrow irrigation towards pivot irrigation systems. In this light, it would be more effective for government funding to be used in promoting water trade than subsidising the cost of irrigation technologies.

• The opportunity costs of meeting environmental flow and salinity reduction targets are also reduced where water efficient technologies and water trading are utilised. However, where these environmental targets are stringent, the economic burden will be substantial even if water trading or irrigation technologies are used. Where a significant reallocation of water for environmental flows or reduction in salinity is envisaged, the resulting opportunity costs should ideally be justified by the environmental benefits that are generated.

• A dual-instrument, simultaneously managing water use and deep drainage through separate instruments, is unnecessary. Surface water caps alone provide sufficient

Author
Categories
Sponsor
Type
Web Highlight
Off

Significance, mechanism and new management strategies of inducible tolerance

Abstract

Insects can respond to selection pressure by mobilising new defence mechanisms. In contrast to recessive resistance mechanisms based on rare target site mutations in receptor proteins, leading to extreme resistance to high B. thuringiensis (Bt) toxin concentrations, we observed a “hidden” inducible immune and metabolic tolerance in field derived laboratory populations of H. armigera to Cry1Ac and Cry2Ab toxins, with potential to cause ecological and economic problems in cotton production. Given that offspring from insects surviving in the field are tolerant of Bt but do not exhibit resistance to Cry1Ac and Cry2Ab due to target site mutations, it is likely that other mechanism(s) is assisting larvae to survive on certain parts of the plants or late in the season when toxin expression is low. Importantly for cotton bollworm management, we have the following three main outcomes:

1) Tolerance in H. armigera larvae is induced by gut-derived toxins (both Cry1Ac and Cry2Ab) and creates sub-populations of insects that show significant levels of tolerance without displaying mutational changes in a major resistance gene locus. Instead, the tolerant phenotype is caused by differential regulation of immune and metabolic activities (larval induction), and is transmitted to offspring by an epigenetic mechanism showing a maternal effect (embryonic induction). While the epigenetic contribution to incremental increases in tolerance is prominent under low to medium selection pressure, other resistance mechanisms that are transmitted genetically may predominate over time with incremental increase in toxin exposure.

2) Testing gene expression in tolerant and susceptible neonate larvae indicates that a range of genes are expressed significantly differently (both higher and lower expression) in tolerant insects compared to susceptible control. Although some of these differentially expressed genes are important key receptor, putative immune and catalytic genes, most of the differentially regulated genes (up to 190 fold) are unknown in function. By understanding these highly altered unknown genes, it is likely we will gain an understanding of the tolerance mechanism and able to develop management options to specially counter tolerance buildup. Further, significant differential regulation of key receptor genes opens up avenues for further research that may lead to establish monitoring tool to detect inducible tolerance and/or resistance in the field.

3) There appears to be significant developmental penalties under laboratory selection, as evidenced by lowered larval weights and increased developmental times. However, once the populations were kept at constant toxin levels, the developmental penalties slowly diminished over subsequent generations. This could indicate possible genotype selection of allelic combinations of multi-gene functions that reduce developmental penalties. This may in long term provide tolerant populations with the adaptive potential to acquire resistance mechanisms that are genetically transmitted and involve target site mutations in important resistance genes. Our findings have practical significance for adapting pest management protocols to counter inducible tolerance, particularly the importance of susceptible females in blocking this form of resistance.

Lastly, laboratory selected H. armigera (25 generations selected with Cry1Ac, 63 fold resistance) are able to complete their larval development on transgenic cotton expressing Cry1Ac and produced fertile adults (Akhurst et al., 2003). Therefore, whether incremental increases in tolerance can support selection for target site mutations in key receptors allowing insect larvae to survive on Bt-plants is another key issue that requires investigation.

Categories
Sponsor
Type
Web Highlight
Off

National Program for Sustainable Irrigation (NPSI) project (Contingency)

Abstract

Knowledge is fundamental to improving the competitiveness, responsiveness

and levels of innovation that we see in industries. This research project completed interviews with

90 growers of cotton and grains, consultants, extension workers, government researcher officers,

and irrigation equipment suppliers to determine how information and knowledge about water

management and water use efficiency is being used and managed in irrigated cotton and grains. Four key issues affecting water management were identified as having major impacts on water management. Information, knowledge and knowledge sharing. All groups believed that the industry was

responsive to change, willing to continually learn, and that growers, consultants and extension

officers were very willing to share information and knowledge. There was considerable

information that was available to growers and consultants. A major concern, however, among

growers and consultants, was the need for the information to have been tested and applied to

determine its relevance and applicability to specific regions.

Categories
Sponsor
Web Highlight
Off

Post-graduate : Simon White - Partial root zone drying and regulated deficit irrigation for cotton using large mobile irrigation schemes

Abstract

There is currently a shortage of irrigation water available for cotton production in Australia due to recent climatic and legislative conditions. Some growers have responded to this water shortage by changing from traditional furrow irrigation to alternative irrigation systems such as centre pivots and lateral move irrigations (collectively known as large mobile irrigation machines – LMIMs). Improved efficiency of irrigation application, as well as labour savings, have been the main reasons for the increased adoption of LMIMs. The use of LMIMs also enables a higher level of control in water application in terms of irrigation volume, timing and placement. As a result, growers now have much greater control over soil moisture conditions which enables the implementation of improved irrigation management strategies that have the potential for improved crop water use efficiency (WUE).

Two irrigation strategies which have been demonstrated to achieve benefits in terms of crop WUE are partial rootzone drying (PRD) and deficit irrigation (DI). PRD and DI involve manipulating the placement of irrigation water and the moisture deficit maintained in the root zone, respectively. Neither PRD nor DI is able to be applied easily under furrow irrigation. However, both PRD and DI may be able to be implemented under LMIMs within the cotton industry. Deficit irrigation has been shown to be effective at improving WUE in cotton, although it is not widely used within the Australian cotton industry. Similarly, there has been little research conducted to identify whether cotton responds to partial rootzone drying and there is currently little understanding of the way in which DI and PRD strategies could be implemented commercially using LMIMs.

This research investigated the response of cotton to a range of PRD and deficit irrigation strategies under LMIMs. Assessment of the biochemical and physiological response of cotton to irrigation strategies were conducted under glasshouse conditions. Field trials conducted under a commercial centre pivot and lateral move assessed the crop response, soil moisture movement, yield and WUE associated with the implementation of a range of PRD and deficit treatments. Modelling of rainfall probability and soil moisture movement were also undertaken to quantify constraints to the successful commercial implementation of irrigation management strategies such as PRD within the Australian cotton industry.

Author
Categories
Sponsor
Web Highlight
Off

Upgrade to Darling DownsWeather Station Network and Chemical Application Days

Abstract

The Grassroots Program offers Cotton Grower groups the opportunity to apply for community based assistance.

Weather Station Upgrades: The Darling Downs Cotton Growers Inc (DDCGI), and individual growers established 21 weather stations between the period 1996-1998, to provide growers with localised weather information to assist with on-farm management operations. The DDCGI has maintained these stations over this period, and in recent years, been working on major upgrades to digital technology to enable text communication with growers rather than the old analogue voice system. To date 11 stations have been upgraded by the DDCGI, and funding from this grant contributing to upgrading another four stations.

Chemical Application Workshops: It is vital for growers to maintain a high level of responsible chemical use and efficient crop protection through continued improvement, uptake a new technology and adoption of best practice. Spray drift is not only a risk of susceptible crops, non-target and sensitive areas but also to the future access of certain groups of chemicals. In addition, poor application methods and reduced efficacy contribute to the development of resistance. The DDCGI is committed to responsible chemical use and the stewardship of agricultural chemicals. The DDCGI plans to use funding from this grant towards organising three training and extension days across the region, the focus will be on chemical application best practice, spray drift risk management, understanding the local weather conditions and record keeping compliance. The DDCGI will engage the services of Mary O’Brien Rural Enterprises to deliver these workshops.

Author
Categories
Sponsor
Web Highlight
Off

Phosphorus and potassium nutrition of cotton

Abstract

The cotton industry spends about $8M on P fertilizers and about $5M of K fertilizers. This indicates the extent of recognised P and K deficiency. It is envisaged that many cotton-growing soils are nearing deficient status, as continual cotton cropping quickly depletes these nutrients. Identification of these soils through soil and plant testing and formulation of improved fertilizer management practices will avoid nutrient deficiencies that reduce the productivity and profitability of cotton cropping.

Inadequate P and K nutrition are responsible for substantial losses of yield and profitability in cotton farming. Deficencies of both nutrients have been linked with the premature senescence syndrome, although confusion arises between the importance and the interactions of these two nutrients.

Previous research has indicated levels of available soil P at which response to P fertilizer is expected and P fertilizer recommendations for maintaining levels of soil P to adequate crop P nutrition. Similarly, research has been conducted on the association between K nutrition and premature. However, the influence of soil sodicity on the P and K nutrition of cotton has now been recognised and a significant effort is required to determine its importance and economic relevance to production.

Categories
Sponsor
Web Highlight
Off